One of my favorite books, by one of my favorite bassists, just got a major upgrade — and that’s what we’re digging into today.
Hal Robinson is one of our great bass teachers. He teaches at Curtis and Juilliard, and is the longtime former principal bassist of the Philadelphia Orchestra (and before that, the National Symphony). What a career he’s had. I sat down recently to chat with Hal about that career and an update to one of my favorite books.
Hal’s only put out a few books, so when Hal puts out a book, I pay attention. I’ve benefited so much over the decades from two of them — Boardwalkin’ and Strokin’ —, and I’ve covered both on this channel. But Boardwalkin’ has now received an upgrade. Hal told me he’s retired Boardwalkin’ at this point and introduced a refinement called Hitchhikin’.
Why the Revamp?
Hal: The reason I’ve had to revamp Boardwalkin’ is that when I put it together, we pivoted up to the octave G and then went into thumb position. Well, since then, the lower thumb position has become more popular — thumb on D or anywhere in there — but that’s fairly common now.
We had followed the Rabbath system of going to each nodal position — the G, the D, and the G, fourth, fifth, and sixth positions — which was wonderful at the time. But over the years, I realized that if you play in those positions, it’s going to sound washed out.
Some people try to get into their Rabbath position and just play things using all those harmonics, but harmonics are a blessing and a curse. They’re in tune, but you can play a harmonic in a slightly different place each time, so it doesn’t tell you exactly where the other notes are.
So it causes some issues there. And just playing in those zones didn’t help either.
What’s in the Book
This book features a sequence of diatonic scales, moving up and down in register and up and down the bass, along with some very cool arpeggio fingerings. In Boardwalkin’, Hal organized these scales ascending and descending around the major harmonics — you have the Rabbath first position, the second position, the third position, then fourth, fifth, and sixth. I’ve covered this approach extensively on the channel, and I’ll link up some resources.
In Hitchhikin’, similar to Boardwalkin’, Hal has you approach the lower positions using these three Rabbath positions. But this time, he gives indications for every single pivot — you’re keeping the hand frame the same and pivoting between notes, and there’s a dot to indicate that, which wasn’t the case in Boardwalkin’. That’s one difference. Otherwise, it’s pretty similar to Boardwalkin’ to start. There are some changes for sure, but we’ll go through them.

Hal recommends slurring these exercises — you can go through, and slur two, three, four notes, and that reveals a lot of possible holes in your technique.
Slurs, Shifts, and Diction
Hal: When we’re playing Bach, Bach should be shift-free of slurs. You shouldn’t shift in slurs if you can avoid it. And learning it that way, you can apply the same rules to classical music, which should also be clear. Then, when you’re playing romantic music, and you want the shift in the portamento, you can decide where you want it, instead of it just occurring wherever we shift, all over the place.
So in these slurs, that’s why I recommend you practice Hitchhikin’ with slurs — because if you’re doing detaché, you can make all these moves, and your hand doesn’t have to stay adhered to the string or keep things smooth. When you’re pivoting from one note to the next — one to four is a great example — there’s a point where nothing is touching the string. Why doesn’t it bark at the open string? It just goes so fast that it doesn’t have time.
To play clean under slurs, there are three methods I call pull, hammer, and jam. You can either hammer the string down, pull it, or do a jam shift. So when you’re trying to play real clean and with a lot of diction, you need to hammer on the way up, pull on the way down, and occasionally do a very fast shift. I’m a proponent of slow shifts as much as you can, until you have to make it really articulate — and then you have to shift fast. That’s a jam shift. But it’s strictly for diction, not accuracy. The rest of the time, I’m trying to get students to shift as slowly as possible.
The other thing I’ve learned about shifting: the elbow has to precede, because the hand follows. A lot of people try to shift their hand from point A to point B, but if you let the elbow lead — shifting down, let the elbow fall; shifting up, proceed with the elbow — it just runs so much smoother.
I’m letting my hand pivot and not keeping the weight locked down. I’m letting the weight transfer from finger to finger.
Rethinking the Thumb Position
Hal: Traditional technique says put your thumb below, across from two or three.
Jason: Right, right. Did you ever get that?
Hal: Yeah, absolutely. Paul used to say, “Do that,” and he’d say, “Keep your hand like that.” To me, it’s really painful — I can’t even do it now. To me, the best hand position is this: what is your most natural hand position? Look where my thumb is — it’s right straight across from my first finger. I began to understand that the reason to put it across from two or three is so you can squeeze, so you have something to press against, and you need it closer to your fourth finger because it’s a weak finger.
But conversely, the opposite is also true. If we’re playing with gravity and want to utilize weight as much as possible, you don’t need these fingers to be down. You need to let the weight do its part.
Now, moving to the Rabbath second position — my thumb is remaining in the same spot, and I’m pivoting with my hand. If you haven’t gotten into pivoting before, I’ll link up a video on this technique. It’s highly useful —and something Hal uses—even if people do it instinctively; it’s a really helpful way to navigate the bass.
Reaching Third Position: “Bring Thumb Above
Now we reach third position. Hal has an indication here — “BTA,” which means “bring thumb above.” So you’re preparing to move from the traditional lower position to low thumb position. This is a major difference in this revised concept.

Hal: So the idea is: since we’re transferring, now we’re playing a lower thumb. When we play the Rabbath third position — which is D, E, F, E, D, right in the crook of the neck (most basses are D necks) — that position is also where your thumb goes for the start of thumb position. So when we’re playing third position, the hand comes back up, and when it’s on the D string, it brings the thumb and plays the same notes across, then moves up in half-step increments.
And when you move up in half-step increments and play across, you begin to realize there are basically three hand frames. We tune in fourths, so there are basically three scale patterns: one frame is thumb-one-two (half step, whole step, half step), the next frame is half step, whole step, and the final one is two whole steps. So it’s one of those three positions.
You could say, “Well, it’s that simple?” Yeah, it’s really that simple. And when you shift into a position, David Moore talks about this a lot with fractal fingerings — all the fingers know they’re over the notes they should play.
So we’re going up… and now the thumb’s coming up, and it ditches the E string at this point. As soon as we go into low thumb position, we’re just on the A, D, and G strings. That’s another difference from Boardwalkin’, where Hal kept the thumb going up into a fourth position on the E string. This is more practical — it’s actually what most of us would do in terms of fingering, since it’s rare to play that high on the E string.
Thumb Position vs. Lower Position Technique
Hal: This is a thumb-position technique, not a lower-position technique. Why the difference? When we’re up high, the thumb is often your root — it needs to stay down, and the fingers stay in contact (not all pressing) and need to stay in this position. Whereas when you’re playing lower positions with pivot, you do not want to lock your hand up, and you don’t want to cover any notes down there, because your hand already knows where they are.
So up high, we want real form-fitting, with the fingers staying down a lot. Down low, we don’t want that.
From here, we move up the bass step-wise. You can see we have whole steps in one spot, a half step and a whole step in another, and it all depends on the needs, but we’re able to reach everything we need just by adjusting the fingers. Again, a different technique here versus pivoting. And we keep going up step-wise.
Coming Back Down — Another Change from Boardwalking
Now we go back down, and again, this is an adjustment from Boardwalkin’. We basically go up to around the D harmonic and then come back down — we’re not going way up into the stratosphere in Hitchhikin’ like we were in Boardwalking, where we’d go all the way up to sixth position. That’s not something we do that often. This lower register — taking out the E string and going back down — is what we do all the time on the bass, and I find it super useful.
As Hal says in the introduction, his practice suggestion is to practice with slurs. So on day one, I might play separate notes for each bow — say on Monday — then slur two, then slur three, then slur four, and maybe increase the tempo.
Playing With Weight
Hal: I basically play with weight. In my career — I’m 73 now and still playing. I’m going to sub with the (Philadelphia) orchestra in June. I get asked to sub at different places, but usually I pass because I don’t want to disrupt my teaching. I’m always looking to play some, though, and I’m going to do a recital at Wabass and do my part with all that stuff. So I’m still pumping away on the bass. I have a bit of trigger finger and stuff like that, but I still play as relaxed and tension-free as possible. I think that’s a real key.
The Arpeggios

For the arpeggios, which are awesome — they’re a series of major, subdominant, augmented, minor, diminished, and seventh-chord arpeggios. So you’re really looking at your bass three-dimensionally in terms of arpeggios, very similar to the Carl Flesch scale system arpeggios.
These are basically the same as in Boardwalkin’, except Hal’s refined them a bit more to show where everything is. He recommends practicing these with a tuner — I’ve done a whole video on that if you want to learn more. It’s very useful, and this is laid out similarly for every major key.
The Big Takeaway
Hitchhikin’ is an upgrade from Boardwalkin’ — that’s point number one. Point number two: it promotes pivot health down low.
Hal: Always slur the notes — two, three, or four, whatever you can fit in. The slurs on the arpeggios are also very important, because I want students to hear every shift. I don’t want any shifts hidden with a bow change — I want them to hear every shift, nice and slow and easy.
So you hear the pitch, and you get this shifting methodology where you can actually hear the shift and hear where to stop, instead of just jumping for something.
We also talked about introducing “thumbage,” mirroring the fourth position — actually the third position of Simandl, which is D-E-F, and then D-E-F-E-D-C-B-A-G-F-E. Students really need that lower thumb position now because they’ll fall behind if they don’t have it.
Get Your Copy of Hitch-hikin’
I really enjoyed this book. You can get a physical copy from Robertson’s and a digital copy from Arco Music. And check out our wide-ranging interview with Hal wherever you get your podcasts, and in written format.
We discuss topics like this every week in our email newsletter. We also offer free monthly sheet music giveaways, community news, and all sorts of cool opportunities for bass players. If you’re not on the list, consider subscribing!
